
As another Friday night nears, I’m saddened by the fact that my VCR (that’s right, I’m old school) won’t be taping another Bill Maher broadcast until August.
This particular show was one of the top 3 of the season, without a doubt. Guests included Madeline Albright, Princeton professor Dr. Cornel West, Counterterrorism czar Richard Clarke, and musician John Legend.
Most of you have probably seen the show, but for those who haven't, I need to say this: Not only is this show entertaining and funny, it’s important.
It’s a round table discussion on current events that has absolutely not political correctness to it, where conservatives get called on their bullshit often. You will not see anything like this on any talk show or cable news network, ever.
Does it have a progressive bias? Absolutely. Does Maher criticize and come after the Democrats during his hour as well? Damn straight. Pair that up with the countless AM talk shows, cable news programs, and Sunday morning political shows, most of which lean to the right - and even though you've got a show that's unique, it’s a doesn’t even lift the elephant on the other end of the sea saw by a single inch.
Anyway, in case you missed the last show of the season, here are some transcriptional highlights (full transcript
here):
Bill Maher on Bush’s Fish:
Well, here's my favorite story of the week. A German publication did an interview with the president and asked Mr. Bush what was his best moment of his presidency. And he said it was the day that he caught a 7 ½ pound perch. [laughter] I couldn't make that up. [laughter] Now, he leaves out the part that he was fishing in downtown New Orleans …That's—[laughter] [applause] [cheers]
No, he was fishing – he was fishing on his ranch. He has an – he has a man-made lake—[laughter]—that is artificially stocked with fish. And let's not forget the scuba divers who are under there—[laughter]—who actually put the fish on the hook for him. [laughter] [applause] And then Cheney comes over and they literally shoot fish in a barrel. [laughter]
But the part I love is that he says he caught a 7 ½ pound perch, when the biggest perch on record is 4.3 pounds. [laughter] Bush lied and a fish died. That's all I have to say. [laughter] [applause] And Cheney went even further. He said when they pulled the fish out of the water, it greeted them as liberators.
Bill Maher and Madelin Albright on Bush and God:
MAHER: Okay, your – your book is about religion in foreign policy, which is actually on the minds, I think, of a lot of people these days. Is it – do you really think that George Bush thinks that God appointed him to be president? [laughter] I mean, we do hear that a lot. Do you really think he believes that?
ALBRIGHT: Well, he – I have a quote in my book where he actually says it. It's hard to say whether he really believes it, but he does say that God is on our side. And I think it would be better if he actually said what President Lincoln said, which is that we ought to be on God's side. [applause]
MAHER: But – but if God chose George Bush, of all the people in the world. [laughter]…to be president. I mean, how good is God, really? [laughter] [applause] [cheers] ALBRIGHT: As somebody says, “the unhappiest character in the Bible is God because His plan didn't work out.” [laughter] [applause]
Maher and the panel on upcoming events on the Congressional docket before the November elections:
MAHER: Well, you mentioned Karl Rove. He is going to use the flag. That's what – I looked at some of the things that Congress is going to bring up in the summer session right before the election: banning gay marriage, that's going to come up again; flag burning—
LEGEND: The greatest hits. They're bringing them back. [laughter]
MAHER: The greatest hits. [applause] Outlaw cloning. A bill about fetal pain. And, of course, singing the National Anthem in Spanish.
LEGEND: When are people going to realize that they're b.s.-ing them? They do it every two years and then it just goes away. Like when did they work on gay marriage after the election? It was – it was just over; it was gone. Are people going to believe them again?
CLARKE: Well, people don't anymore. I mean, you look at the polls. There's a big difference in the polls between the election and today. In fact, there's a poll that came out today that said if you had the choice between Bill Clinton today and the incumbent, who would you pick? 68% of the people said Bill Clinton. [applause] [cheers]
MAHER: So when Bush picks this guy, General Hayden, to be head of the CIA, that actually is what Karl Rove wants. Because they want a battle where they're saying, “We're the Republicans. We're going to protect you at any costs, where the Democrats are for laws and all that pansy bullshit.” [laughter]
...on 9/11 conspiracy theories:
MAHER: Well, let me ask you then, because everywhere I go, people say to me, “Why don't you cover on your show what really happened on 9/11? Why don't you talk about the fact that a missile was what brought down Flight 93, and that the World Trade Center was a planned explosion?” Do you believe any of those conspiracy theories? Do you think it's even possible?
WEST: No, I don't. I don't believe it. But I know the world is a mysterious place. [laughter] Which means I'm open to coordinated activity in secret places. But I don't believe in conspiracy. [laughter] [applause]
MAHER: Wow. You could be a Republican. [laughter]
LEGEND: I think the government is dishonest and they try to keep secrets from us, but they're not that good at keeping secrets, apparently, because they keep coming out. People keep leaking them. So I don't believe that they could coordinate that, that well, and pull it off without us finding out.
CLARKE: Yes.
MAHER: Yeah, it seems like if they couldn't get a helicopter into the Superdome, they probably couldn't get – get some of this stuff going.
CLARKE: All these conspiracy theories have the two basic problems: one, they believe the government is competent. [laughter] [applause]
WEST: The sad thing is, you know, when they talk about welfare, they always talk about personal responsibility, personal responsibility. But when it comes to their actions, who takes responsibility? Hardly anybody at all. [applause] That's what you call not just moral inconsistency. That's what you call unadulterated hypocrisy. [applause]
CLARKE: The WMD issue, the White House now says, “CIA gave us the wrong information.” No, they didn't. CIA gave them fairly decent information that they took and exaggerated and extrapolated; talked about mushroom clouds. None of that is in what CIA gave them.
LEGEND: They picked the information they wanted and then they ignored the stuff that didn't fit the story.
CLARKE: And then they blamed CIA and give them Freedom Medals. But that's a whole other story. [laughter]
...on President Ahmadinejad’s letter to Bush:
MAHER: I can't – how can you do that? Frank, please. [laughter] So he sent the first letter from an Iranian president directly to an American president in 27 years. He, of course, sends it to the one president who can't read. [laughter] [applause] And, look, this guy is a total nutcase and a dangerous loon, we all know that. But, you know, it was an opening, was it not? It was an 18-page letter. And Condoleezza Rice basically said, “Talk to the hand.” [laughter] Wasn't there something to build on in this?
WEST: The structure of the letter was very interesting, because, as you recall, the letter says, “Mr. Bush, I understand you to be a follower of Jesus Christ. If you love Jesus Christ and you're supposed to be concerned with the least of these, why don't your policies in any way reflect a concern for the poor and the rejected, and the luckless and the landless?” [applause] Now, this is a very interesting strategy, you know. It's what philosophers call “eminent critique.” Which is to say, you being where people start themselves. They accept the premise.
WEST: And then you bring critique to bear on their platform.
MAHER: He was trying to find some common ground. He was saying, “I'm a religious nut; you're a religious nut.” [laughter] Can't we just—
WEST: But he doesn't – he doesn't mention Islam hardly at all. Just Jesus Christ. Did you notice it in there?
CLARKE: Absolutely.
WEST: In the letter, it was a fascinating move.
CLARKE: Absolutely. But, you know, in the height of the Cuban Missile Crisis, Kennedy got a letter, and it was not a very good one from Khrushchev. And he decided to ignore it and respond not about what was in the letter, but respond through a back channel. And, you know, right now, we've got an opening. Forget what was in the letter. The letter was 18 pages of blah-blah. You know, it was just – no one can understand the letter.
LEGEND: Long letter.
WEST: Yeah, it was a long letter.
CLARKE: And Bush doesn't read things that are 18 pages long anyway. [laughter] So – but the point is, it was an opening.
MAHER: Yeah.
CLARKE: That's – it was a symbol. It was an opening. And what do we say? “We refuse to talk to them because that would be rewarding bad behavior.” (pauses) We're not running a third grade class. [laughter] [applause] [West shakes Clarke's hand]
...on Rove’s gay marriage strategy:
MAHER: [overlapping] Everybody knows – everybody knows this was a big brouhaha during the 2004 campaign, and the right wing was furious at John Kerry. And let's go back just for a second and talk about what exactly happened. He was asked in the debate – was asked the question – he didn't bring it out of nothing – “Do you believe homosexuality is a choice?” And John Kerry said, “If you were to talk to Dick Cheney's daughter, who is a lesbian, she would tell you that she's just being who she is, who she was born as.” Now, considering the fact that this issue wouldn't even have been on the table except that Bush was pushing gay marriage—
LEGEND: Bingo.
MAHER: [overlapping]—it doesn't seem like such an outrageous proposition.
CLARKE: But the point is – the one that you made – is that Rove put the gay issue on 16 ballots for one reason: to get people out to vote, the religious right, who otherwise would not come out to vote. The reason Ohio went for Bush instead of Kerry by 59,000 votes is entirely because the gay issue was on the ballot. And twice the number of African Americans in Ohio voted for Bush as they did nationally, because they were able to – Rove is brilliant – Rove was able to get to them on this issue.
LEGEND: But – but they were also trying to suppress the black vote in Ohio . Let's talk about that.
WEST: That's true, too.
LEGEND: How they were going into neighborhoods, black neighborhoods, and trying to make sure they were confused about where to vote in Ohio . They didn't want us to vote in Ohio . I'm from Ohio , by the way. [applause]
CLARKE: Neighborhoods – neighborhoods where they had done the polling and knew that the people were going to vote for Kerry, they did that.
LEGEND: Yes. Which is still – the vast majority of black folks voted for Kerry. And they wanted to make sure we didn't vote as much. That's true.
CLARKE: They're going to try it again this year. This year, instead of gay marriage, it's going to be gay adoption, which they're going to put on ballots across the country so they can get that 10% of the religious right out to vote, who otherwise wouldn't come out to vote.
LEGEND: And you would think they'd feel betrayed by now, because they never get what they – what they go and vote for. [laughter]
LEGEND: Yeah, you would think they'd feel betrayed.
WEST: Oh, you mean the right wing themselves?
LEGEND: The right wing. Like they're going to the polls and, “Yeah, we're going to get this amendment.”
WEST: Yeah, that's a good point.
LEGEND: And they never get their amendment. [laughter] [applause]
WEST: But they get a kind of – they get a kind of symbolic satisfaction. It's like it's cathartic.
MAHER: That's right. That's Karl Rove's genius.
And finally, perhaps the most brilliantly delivered point of the night, Bill Maher’s new rule:MAHER: And finally, New Rule: George Bush has to stop laughing at himself. [laughter] When you're incompetence literally costs lives, giggling at it isn't cute or funny. You know, there's a guy who's been running around the country pretending he's the president, and I believe his name is George Bush. [laughter] [applause] [cheers] And he wants everyone to know that he doesn't take himself too seriously. Which is working out great, because now nobody else in the world does either. [laughter]
You know, if the Republicans really want to joke around, I've got one for you. Knock, knock.
AUDIENCE: Who's there?
MAHER: Hillary. [laughter] [applause]
Now, this is our last show of the season, and I'm rather proud that we've gone all 13 weeks without once making George Bush the subject of our show-ending editorial. Because I didn't want to start sounding like a broken record. Or, to you kids, a degraded MP3 file. [laughter] [applause] Oh, there may have been a stray George Bush punchline here and there. But, come on. I am a comedian and he is a retard. [laughter] [applause] [cheers]
But, fuck it, this is our—[laughter] [applause] [cheers]—this is our last show. This is our last show for a while and I just want to say that when we come back on August 25 th , the week of Bill Clinton's 60 th birthday, and a great time for him to do the show. Wouldn't you love to see him do the show, folks? [applause] [cheers]—Bill Clinton, everywhere I go. So, your move, Mr. President. But when we come back, I hope we're only months away from the beginning of impeachment proceedings. [applause] [cheers]
But, wait. But not for what you think. Now, of course there is a laundry list of valid reasons for impeaching this president. But George Bush and his nest of vipers don't deserve to be impeached with dignity for transgressions involving lofty affairs of state. They deserve the far worse state that Clinton got: being impeached for absolutely nothing at all! [applause]
And that's why I want to impeach Bush over the fact that he lied about that fish! [laughter] [applause] [sustained cheers]
He said he caught a perch twice as large as any perch that's ever been caught! [laughter] And that's a lie about a fish! [laughter] In a time of war! [laughter] And if he will lie about a fish, then…something, something, something, what do we tell the children? [laughter] What do we tell Mrs. Paul?! [laughter] That perch was as American as a McDonald's fish sandwich. Assuming for the sake of argument that a McDonald's fish sandwich contained fish. [laughter] [applause]
So, Mr. President, don't laugh at yourself, because breaking the law is not cute. Having Americans torture people isn't adorable. Leaving poor people to drown wasn't enchanting. And WMD's wasn't a shaggy dog story. So, I'll make a deal with you. We won't impeach you if you just stay on your estate – I mean “ranch”—[laughter]—and fish on your man-made lake. For perch. Maybe you'll beat your own record. [laughter]
But, for the next three years, just don't touch anything. [laughter] [applause] I was wrong when I criticized you for taking too much vacation time. It couldn't be more the reverse. [laughter] Take all the “me” days you want. [laughter] [applause]
But if you get any big ideas and try to do something, you know, like go to Mars or put the Ten Commandments on the flag—[laughter]—or turn the ports over to the Amish—[laughter]—then we're going to have to put you in the only place we can be sure we can be safe from you. And it looks like this. [photo shown of David Blaine's water-filled Plexiglas globe] [applause] [cheers]